May the source be with you, but remember the KISS principle ;-)
Home Switchboard Unix Administration Red Hat TCP/IP Networks Neoliberalism Toxic Managers
(slightly skeptical) Educational society promoting "Back to basics" movement against IT overcomplexity and  bastardization of classic Unix

Financial Skeptic Bulletin, 2009

Prev | Contents | Next

Jan Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec

January 2009 Predictions

This page is written as a reminder of trends that might logically occur in some (may be not too distant) future in a hope that understanding larger trends can helps me to avoid attempts to catch a falling knife. I doubt about my ability to get the return above inflation for the next three years at least but I would like to avoid additional, unnecessary losses induced by Bubblevision or market hype. It is also might present the economic situation in terms more understandable to programmers and IT specialists. Actually that's pretty sad that neoclassical economics operates with those primitive (and obscure) linear models, models which bear no or little resemblance to reality "in a short run" instead of using programs in some standard simulation language. For example can't those economic professors just learn Excel and present their hypothesis in Excel models terms ;-). It's actually pretty funny how they try to use mathematics...     

For those who have 401K plans and are concerned about them here is my list of  few things which probably take longer then many expect (this 100% derivative material and as in all forecasts it would be great is 60% of predictions are correct ;-).  You are warned):

  1. The country was on the wrong track for too long.  Financial crises is the payback for excesses and will hit 401K investors in 2009 regardless of whether you are a saint or a sinner. Losses can be substantial.  This crisis is now completely new and should probably be considered as the second leg of the previous which was artificially terminated by 1% rates, which is turn created housing bubble. The world cannot grow its way out of this slowdown, says Rogoff, professor of economics at Harvard and former IMF chief economist. Because today’s mess was many years in the making and there is no easy, painless exit strategy. Painful structural shifts are necessary.  USA policymakers will gradually adopt the necessary changes that but it takes a long time to reverse the ill effects of such an incredible boom and two decades of easy monetary policy.
    Inflation stabilization cannot be indefinitely compromised to support bail-out activities. However convenient it may be to have several years of elevated inflation to help bail out homeowners and financial institutions, the gain has to be weighed against the long-run cost of re-anchoring inflation expectations later on.

     Willem Buiter in his Welcome to a world of diminished expectations noted in August 5, 2008:

    From a cyclical perspective, things look bad for Europe, the US and most of the global economy. My contribution to summer cheer is to note that longer-term local and global economic prospects are likely to be worse than expected. So welcome to boom and bust. Welcome to subdued long-term growth prospects.

    While downturn started in financial sector "sector rotation" is imminent. Real economy just stated sliding and entered or will enter the recession.  We are entering a full blown recession and a very serious one. As of September 17 it looks like financial bubble burst. But seizing up of liquidity and Asia will stop pumping money into the USA and slowing consumer, residential and non-residential financial create huge pressure of companies. 

    Be stoic in absorbing losses and do not try to compensate for losses with risky investments or dreams about the market bottom ("catching falling knife). That's a real problem for me personally as I lack patience needed for a good investor.  See recent Mark Faber interview for how a very good investor views the current situation and what course of actions he recommends. 

  2. For 401K investors, who are baby boomers,  it might be better to stay out of the way for the next year. The Bottom feeders might keep coming up empty: the issue with Buffett/Rothschild’s recommendation to buy when people are fearful is that most 401K investors like frogs is slowly warming pot: they does not seem to be even slightly fearful until it's too late. 

    The open question is whether we’re in for a bad couple of years, or a bad decade,” said Kenneth S. Rogoff, a former chief economist at the IMF, who now is a professor at Harvard. There will be rallies in stocks. Some might be quite substantial, but that doesn’t mean we’re in a bull market. In article, "Traversing wild market swings,"  El-Erian of PIMCO fame put a very blunt warning to 401K investors:
    Successful risk management must reflect the fact that markets are now in the grip of three distinct but reinforcing forces that will play out over a number of quarters.
    • First, look for further balance sheet contractions in the financial sector that will continue to suck oxygen out of, and undermine risk appetite in credit and equity markets. This is part of a long-term process of de-risking that is currently driven by markets but will soon have a more important regulatory dimension.
    • Second, markets are yet to adequately price the morphing of the credit crunch into a full-scale US economic disruption. Prepare for even stronger headwinds fuelled by declining real income and eroding household wealth.
    • Third, there are no easy policy solutions. Instead, policy makers face an extremely difficult situation in which any action, no matter how well-intentioned, entails unstable feedback loops and impose distortions elsewhere. Collateral damage cannot be avoided, yet its exact characterisation is uncertain given the extent of still-hidden vulnerabilities in both the real economy and the financial sector. are well advised to stay on the sidelines, focused on the probability that these same markets will also be treacherous for at least the remainder of this year.

    Typical baby boomer 401K account already is probably already $10K-$20K in red. I think since the beginning of the year more and more 401K investors are getting an understanding of how steep the fall might be. Attempt to re-enter those markets on dips is like trying to catch a falling knife: stock markets are yet to discover the full extend of the old shock and credit crunch.

  3. Dollar might be structurally weak and that prevents stabilization. Joseph Stiglitz  consider dollar to be doomed, but euro not up to the task of global currency either.  Structural problem with economy as it was crippled by Reaganomics (aka "woodoo economics'' were people earn living selling to each other financial derivatives) will not go away by themselves, require huge investments into infrastructure and manufacturing and need years to fix.  Now it is clear the relying on credit as the engine of growth backfired: we've issued more paper than the economy can ever pay back -- given its  size. How long foreign central banks will continue to play the game is a difficult question to answer but the trend of moving away from the dollar is certainly apparent. Bulls, and "what me worry types" can certainly find enough sucker rallies to continue to live in a fool's paradise (Financial stock can be up 35%, but the underlying economic situation hasn't changed a bit, except revealing the cluelessness of the guys in charge), but as Herb Stein noted what can't go on forever, stops. That means that either interest rates go through the roof, or the dollar really collapses, or both.

    Inflation is the other side of weakening of the dollar:

    Increases in commodity prices such as oil and gas and the decline in value of the U.S. dollar against other currencies are fueling inflationary pressures across the U.S. The year-over-year wholesale and consumer price increase, including food and energy, is running close to 5%, according to June government numbers. The country hasn't seen those rates in nearly 20 years. Excluding food and energy, the rate is about half that (2.4%), but even that is "above the level consistent with price stability," according the Federal Reserve Bank in Philadelphia.

    While there are arguments over just how inflation is measured and what the inflation rate is, there is agreement that either measure is higher than it should be -- and the outlook is deteriorating.

  4. Pervasive lack of confidence in government and financial institutions created no-win situation on many fronts [NC, July 22, 2008]. Merrill Lynch recently warned that the United States could face a foreign "financing crisis" within months as the full consequences of the Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac mortgage debacle spread through the world. Hiroshi Watanabe, Japan's chief regulator urged Japanese banks and life insurance companies to treat US agency debt with caution.

    The financial crisis continues to create victims. This is not only Peak Oil but Peak Credit. Not only people but also crazy but dominant ideas like market fundamentalism will go the way of Baer Sterns. The idea that financial markets are efficient now looks very unconvincing, to say the least. This is not a liquidity this is solvency crisis. The banks now have deep and justified concern about the solvency of their peers:  the quality of the underlying collateral for much of the lending of previous years – housing – continues to deteriorate. The Case-Shiller 20-city index declined by 18 per cent in nominal terms and 22 per cent in real terms between its peak in mid-2006 and April of this year. This rate of decline is also accelerating.

    As Paul De Grauwe wrote in Financial Times (Jul 22, 2008):

    Its proponents told us that when financial markets were left free, they would work miracles. Savings would be channeled to the most promising investment projects, thereby boosting economic growth and welfare. In addition, these financial markets would spread risk around over a large number of participants, thereby lowering the risk of doing business, again boosting growth and welfare. In order to achieve these wonders, financial markets had to be freed from the shackles of government control.

    The country that embodied these principles most was the US. Helped by the missionary zeal of successive American administrations and pushed by international financial institutions, country after country freed their financial markets from pernicious government controls, hoping to share in these economic wonders.

    The credit crisis has destroyed the idea that unregulated financial markets always efficiently channel savings to the most promising investment projects. Millions of US citizens took on unsustainable debts, pushed around by bankers and other “debt merchants” who made a quick buck by disregarding risks. While this happened, the US monetary authorities marveled at the creativity of financial capitalism. When the bust came, a large number of Americans who had been promised a new life in their beautiful homes were told to move out. This boom and bust cycle cannot have been an example of efficient channeling of savings into the most promising investment projects.

    The fact that unregulated financial markets fail to deliver the wonders of efficiency does not mean that governments should take over. That would be worse. What it does mean is that a new equilibrium must be found in which tighter regulation is reintroduced, aimed at reducing the propensities of too many in the markets to take on excessive risks. The need to re-regulate financial markets is enhanced by the fact that central banks, backed by governments, provide an insurance against liquidity risks. Such insurance inevitably leads to moral hazard and excessive risk-taking. The insurer cannot avoid monitoring and regulating the behavior of those who obtain this insurance.

    Satyajit Das, well-known expert in derivatives  asked the rhetoric question (Markman, July 5, 2008) that is  applicable to Fed officials like  Helicopter Bernanke too:

    "Given that the bank presidents have been consistently wrong about everything they've said about their losses until now, why on earth would anyone believe them  now? "

    At the same time the Fed policies can be viewed as an example of cargo cult economics -- the repetition of past solutions without any recognition that we're living in a different world. The core problem of the US economy is the orgy of bad debt indulged for the past 7 years and its broken, oversized, untrustworthy, "pass the buck" financial system.  Manufacturing is now only 11.7% of GDP (2007, source: NAM).

    A pervasive lack of confidence in our economy and our government is as serious a threat as a deterioration of the balance sheets of our financial sector. More over, a stable financial system is as important to renewed economic growth as is any fiscal stimulus, much as confidence in sustained aggregate demand is as important as balance sheet integrity to the financial system. But we should learn from our mistakes and act pragmatically to regulate markets as they exist in fact, not theory. The repeal of the Glass-Steagall Act, coupled with cheap money and tolerance for ever greater risk, led to this situation. Unbridled use of short-selling can be destructive of value and contrary to growth and investment. Speculation may play a role in the rise in commodities prices and, if so, risks more pain if the commodities bubble bursts.

    Here is one comment from NC readers:

    ... Can I add a few more?

    • Food inflation
    • Healthcare spend being a totally ridiculous % of GDP in relation to its productivity.
    • Military spending ditto.
    • Widespread incompetence and corruption in the administration(s)...
  5. Equities are undergoing structural change with new (and few) winners and many (mostly old, established firms) as losers; they are probably further to fall from June 30, 2008 level.  Earnings growth will be harder and harder to get. From one hand we should never discount the resilience of the US economy. There are a lot of companies which are positioned well to weather this period. Still the majority of fund managers dismiss hopes of double-digit earnings growth this and next year as "fantasy".

    The US will repatriate some manufacturing market share, no doubt, but it will be small compared to the loss of market volumes around the world. Take furniture. Transports costs are making China less competitive, so the US is getting some back, but at the same time the US domestic market for furniture has almost evaporated.

    According to Douglas Cliggott, chief investment officer at Dover Management LLC, profit margins may bottom in late 2009 or early 2010 (Bloomberg, July 29). But all such predictions should be taken with  a grain of salt.

    Also in June 2006 A report by the RBS's research team warns that the S&P 500 index is likely to fall by more than 300 points to around 1050 by September as "all the chickens come home to roost" from the excesses of the global boom, with contagion spreading across Europe and emerging markets.

    Business debt continued to expand and in the first quarter grew 10.8% yoy. The interest payments remains at historical lows (relative to profits).  This explains why businesses have been shifting the means to finance itself, from bond issuance to bank loans. But risks are growing: the financial gap remains at a high level, indicating the need for external financing in order to keep current operations. So far the massive liquidity injections from the rest of the world, or what Brad Setser calls “the quiet bailout.” continued unabated.

    Companies and markets are undergoing structural changes due to rise of commodity prices and the present turmoil is just the beginning of the decades-long transformation.  In his Sept 20, 2007 column Are we headed for an epic bear market - MSN Money Markman sited  Satyajit Das opinion:

    He's not sure if it will play out like the 13-year decline of 90% in Japan from 1990 to 2003 that followed the bursting of a credit bubble there, or like the 15-year flat spot in the U.S. market from 1960 to 1975. But either way, he foresees hard times as an optimistic era of too much liquidity, too much leverage and too much financial engineering slowly and inevitably deflates.

    Normally, after a month as bad as June 2008, you'd expect some sort of reversion, a sucker rally. At the same time many companies now feel they hit the wall of limits of growth and long term the equities look overvalued. According to Patrick Legland (Societe Generale) earning estimates are too high. Inflation is undermining confidence.  There are several negative factors in play now:

  6. Consumer is done. While consumption in the USA is dominated by rich and as such is resistant to downturns even high net worth families appeared to be cutting their discretionary spending on luxury goods and services as the global economy slows (Financial Times). Long term, Americans may have no choice but to spend less, save more and reduce debts — in short, to live within their means.
  7. M&A mania is over. Stock prices were partially (especially in 2007) driven by debt expansion and M&A wave. M&A craziness is over and the money supply dwindles. 
  8. Current consensus that earnings will rise 4.1% looks too optimistic. European market can fall another 10-15%. Japan can turn positive for a year. 401K investors are slowly focusing on defensive assets. They just can't believe that the stock market wealth machine is running seriously in reverse, so instead of selling they stop buying and hold on to hope.
  9. Reckless deregulation is gone. High risk has been rewarded in the past by government (easy monetary policy), legislation (the repeal of Glass-Steagall), and the powerful brainwashing (the Wall Street marketing machine). Those rewards dissipate quickly when you see that you have built your 401K house on sand.
  10. Decline of S&P500 might be only half-completed. As of mid July, 2008 S&P 500 decline might be only half-competed and it still might have another 200-300 points  to drop from 1300 level. So the drop to the level of 1050 in S&P 500 does not look completely outrageous and that consideration might help to cool the desire to buy on dips. As Martin Wold wrote on July 15, 2008 in his FT column:

    ... the balance of economic forces is contractionary:

    • financial crises and property price collapses in the US and a number of other high-income countries;
    • soaring commodity prices;
    • and inflationary pressures, particularly in emerging countries.

    It is hard to see any outcome other than a sustained slowdown in the world economy. It is even quite likely that the trend growth of the world economy is considerably slower than was hoped a few years ago.

    Furthermore, some of the risks could combine in dangerous ways.
    ...The good news is that the world economy has held up surprisingly well. The bad news is that the risks remain squarely on the downside. It will take some luck and much judgment to pass through the storms unscathed.

  11. A permanent doubling of food and energy prices might permanently slow the rate of economic growth . While correction are possible and some correction is imminent this is long-term factor which might depress growth for years to come (is not a large part of the current GDP junk worth of disposing ?).  Effects are multiplied by the slow recovery of financials:
    The ... slow recovery of financial markets that I think is likely suggests that the U.S. economy will be subject to substantial headwinds for some time."

    From Fed Governor Frederic Mishkin: Global Financial Turmoil and the World Economy.

  12. Approximate time for bottoming of real estate is probably around 2-3 years (2010-2011).

    The subprime crisis is the joint product of perverse incentives and historical aberration of extremly loose fiscal policy. It is buy-and large a structural problem that signifies "Peak Credit". Investors in subprime-related financial claims made ex ante unwise investments, which seem to be best understood as the result of a conflict of interest between asset managers and their clients. The next wave of resets (Alt-A mortgages) will peak only in December 2009. Alt-A is the new subprime. A chart from Calculated Risk shows the starting next year a second tsunami of bad mortgage debt hitting and lasting another 2 years or more:

    It is possible that May 2008 was the last month in which the year-over-year rate of decline of prices of houses accelerates.  But in absolute terms real estate prices will probably continue to decline for many months. And there is no catalysts for a sharp rebound any time soon so this will be L-shape recovery. noted that enough houses are on the market to satisfy demand for the next two-and-a-half years without building a single new one.

    As for the length of further declines, in July 2008 Citigroup chairman Win Bischoff has warned that house prices in the United States are likely to keep falling for another two years. He also said he expected the credit crunch could continue through 2009 (NC July 20, 2008). Early 2010 is the year in which effects of Alt-A and Option ARM resets will convert into additional foreclosures  (NK, July 22, 2008) The housing market is unlikely to be out of the woods before the dust settles and that means 2011. Many don't see a rebound until 2012.

    Some areas might never recover. Distant (more then 60 miles from metropolis like Pocono in NJ) suburbia housing recovery requires a pullback in oil and unemployment. With high oil prices transportation costs became substantial (reversal of death of distance) unless the residents convert to the most efficient cars (Prius) and prices stabilize at present level.  The might mean resurgence of cities. Suburbia living might become a dying ideal.

    Houses need to shrink like cars: heating costs of newer, larger houses are an acute problem as home builders chose to stop building homes for the average schmuck. Due to heating and maintenance price of  McMansions that were bought during this housing boom might go the way of the Ford Expedition and Lincoln Continental.

    According to Calculated Risk: "Looking at the price-to-rent ratio based on the Case-Shiller index, the adjustment in the price-to-rent ratio is probably more than half way complete as of Q1 2008 on a national basis."  IMF Paper  also suggests that US Housing is overvalued by 14%, and is likely to overshoot on downside. If we assume that correction is half-way complete and it took two years for the first part of the correction it is logical to assume that it will take another two years for the correction to finish. The second half actually can take longer: commercial real estate will follow residential and might considerably prolong the crisis:

  13. Approximate time for stabilization of energy prices -- a decade or two. Oil prices probably will never retreat to $40 per barrel level. This might be a deep and painful structural shift for the whole economics. And it might negatively effect the prices of suburban real estate as well as suburbia large malls retailers. Cities might experience resurgence. There might also be popping of the perception of perpetual growth.
  14. Approximate time for  resolution of the financial institutions crisis and deleveraging -- at least a decade.  Financial sector need to shrink substantially as its business model was broken. Not only subprime, CDO and LBO excesses will soon blow in investor face. Cassidy says 300 U.S. Banks may fail over the next three years  Marc Faber thinks that most  banks are insolvent and are on life support ( See $1.6 trillion: new estimate on writedowns). Financial bubble went terribly wrong and bursts. On hot of tat is complete opacity when nobody know what is the liabilities of partners are.

     "I think a lot of banks are already bankrupt … but they hide their rotten assets … in categories where you don't really need to value them," 

    Roubini also thinks that "A systemic banking crisis will go on for awhile, with hundreds of banks going belly up." Soros in BBC interview think that as of Septmber 2008 we are only at the beginning of the financial crisys. Mr Soros told Newsnight that he expects more banks to collapse.

    Reader Steve e-mailed some observations about recent FDIC actions that bear on this discussion to Naked Capatalism blog.

    The huge losses embedded in household mortgage portfolios make the current banking crisis different, and the regulatory response is different as well. The reason for the concern over foreclosures has more to do with bank accounting than with bleeding heart concerns for mortgagors. When a property is foreclosed, a bank must write off the difference between the loan balance and the appraised value of the property (with a further downward adjustment for disposition costs). A write-off is a reduction in capital, so the bank's capital primary capital ratio is affected. Banks are prohibited from writing owned real estate back up. On the other hand, if the bank only recognizes an impairment on the loan, there is a reserve against capital but no write-off. So the loss can be strung out over time, and regulators can allow banks a fair amount of leeway in forming `opinions' about loss severities. In other words, an insolvent bank can appear to be adequately or even well capitalized. I believe an argument could be made that many institutions would be stone insolvent if foreclosures and write-offs were being done in accordance with traditional banking and regulatory practices. In particular, I suspect that the vast majority of foreclosed mortgages are investor owned rather than bank owned, and that regulators have adopted `go-slow' oversight in anticipation of legislative action on foreclosures.

    The next stage of financial institutions crisis might be connected with open ARM mortgages  and a huge accommodation for auction rate securities.  The latter  will be very painful for banks. As Aline van Duyn  wrote in FT on Aug 2, 2008:

    "Market is collapsing. No more $2k dinners at CRU!!" This message was sent in an e-mail by a Merrill Lynch executive to a friend in November last year, according to a complaint filed this week by William Galvin, Massachusetts' Secretary of State.

    The market in question is, according to the complaint, the auction rate securities market. This was never regarded as the most exciting arm of finance to work in, although it may well have funded plenty of pricy dinners. [CRU, by the way, is located on New York's 5th Avenue and boasts a 65,000-bottle wine cellar and dishes such as live sea scallops with mozzarella.]

    Auction rate securities, which grew to be a $330bn market, were used by providers of student loans and municipal borrowers such as schools and hospitals to borrow money.

    Then, after years of humming along nicely and offering a slightly higher yield than cash, the market collapsed in February, a result of shattered confidence in bond guarantees that backed many of the securities' high credit ratings. The timing of the e-mail quoted above was important. In February, Merrill Lynch salespeople were telling clients that the bank "by all indications, is committed to this product" and the securities represented "a good, conservative, reasonable investment", the complaint says. However, comments such as the one made about the collapsing market, suggest otherwise, Mr Galvin argues. Merrill Lynch said it was "disappointed" the action was filed because "it ignores the only reason our advisers sold auction rate securities: they believed they were good investments for clients willing to trade some liquidity for higher return".

    The legal tussles will continue. Yet, it is clear auction rate securities are fast emerging as the potential poster child of cracking down on the perceived Wall Street abuses that fuelled the credit bubble. There is a strong desire among law-makers and law-enforcers to find a way to hammer Wall Street for the mortgage meltdown. The auction rate securities market seems to be delivering it. As well as a case against Merrill, civil charges have been filed against UBS over its role in the market and two former Credit Suisse brokers are facing a criminal probe. Citigroup said yesterday it had received subpoenas from regulators in connection with auction rate securities.

    There are two reasons that developments in auction rate securities should be very closely watched. First, they could be very painful for banks. A bank executive told me he thought auction rate securities could be "bigger than the research scandals" - referring to Eliot Spitzer's probe of research practices, which resulted in a $1.4bn settlement. Bigger in terms of payments? Bigger in terms of the reputational damage? Both, he said.

    ... ... ...

    So, keep watching this in-the-making case study. The auction rate securities market is a historical relic, and few people expect its return, but it is not making a quiet exit.

  15. Things might became really bumpy in 2009: despite a housing mess, securitization (and related credit crunch) the U.S. economy might not slide but advance 1% or 2% in 2009

News collected below suggest that it makes sense for 401K investor to be conservative and try to increase cash position those days. It's bad time to hunt for bargains, unless those are extreme bargans. Preservation of capital might be the highest possible achievement in 2008 and 2009 for 401K investors who were put in Procrustes bed of randomly selected stock funds and few bond funds in their 401K accounts. Especially for baby-boomers.

Speculative runs after a slump like we experienced in April, 2008 are a dangerous thing to follow. Did Fed unlock the credit crunch at this stage? The answer is no. Did banks solve securitization and over-leveraging problems ? The answer is: "The major banks are barely holding on to life...".  Regular banks should probably be priced for zero growth.  Investment banks are in real trouble due to off-balance accounts and can experience negative growth as their business model has been broken.

Another "sucker rally" can follow this July, 2008 slump (it might be late autumn "president rally" ).

Disclaimer: This page is mainly an exercise in self-education that was made available to others in a hope that it might be useful. The stories on this page are financial blogs stories picked by me from the Internet; in addition to being late some or most represent a typical market noise that is mostly irrelevant. You are warned !

Please read them critically and apply sound judgment. Very plausible stories and explanations can in retrospect be dead wrong. All 401K investors should be warned about the 95% rule, which states that about 95% of what you read about finance and economy is either wrong or irrelevant. In investment, 95% is probably a very conservative number. This site is no exception...

How predictions fared

  1. [Wrong] The country was on the wrong track for too long. Financial crises is the payback for excesses and will hit 401K investors in 2009 regardless of whether you are a saint or a sinner. Losses can be substantial.

    Reality check: Not only this prediction was fuzzy, it looks like this prediction is completely wrong. 2009 will be an up year for 401K investors no matter in what class of instruments they were invested. Bond investors probably are up 7% or so, 'all equity investors" 20% or so.

  2. [Wrong] For 401K investors, who are baby boomers, it might be better to stay out of the way for the next year.

    Reality check: This prediction is completely wrong. Those who converted everything to cash at the end of 2008, have 2008 losses without 2009 upside. Some trading would be very beneficial for 401K accounts. Investors who stayed in equities got back approximately 20% of losses (which were in 2008 approximately 28%). Total loss in comparison with stable value funds for two year period is still substantial but it is much less for those who participated in the rally.

    Unfortunately most 401K investors were burned too badly in 2008 and as of November 26 bonds funds have attracted $315bln of new inflows while there is virtually no inflows into equity funds. This Fed financed and zero rate induced rally was for and by Wall Street sharks not a regular 401K investor.

  3. [Right, but with a caveat] Dollar might be structurally weak and that prevents stabilization. Joseph Stiglitz consider dollar to be doomed, but euro not up to the task of global currency either.

    Reality check: Dollar his 2008 lows in November 2008, but few 401K investors participated in related gold rally. Actually gold was not recommended in this advice/prediction.

  4. [Partially right but too fuzzy] Pervasive lack of confidence in government and financial institutions created no-win situation on many fronts [NC, July 22, 2008]. Merrill Lynch recently warned that the United States could face a foreign "financing crisis" within months as the full consequences of the Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac mortgage debacle spread through the world. Hiroshi Watanabe, Japan's chief regulator urged Japanese banks and life insurance companies to treat US agency debt with caution.

    The financial crisis continues to create victims. This is not only Peak Oil but Peak Credit. Not only people but also crazy but dominant ideas like market fundamentalism will go the way of Baer Sterns. The idea that financial markets are efficient now looks very unconvincing, to say the least. This is not a liquidity this is solvency crisis. The banks now have deep and justified concern about the solvency of their peers...

    Reality check: there was no foreign financial crisis in 2009. Lack of confidence pushed gold to new highs. Market fundamentalism is really dead now, including absurd idea that markets are efficient. Looks like banks are still hiding losses and many small banks were closed, but none of big banks went bust in 2009.

  5. [Completely wrong] Equities are undergoing structural change with new (and few) winners and many (mostly old, established firms) as losers; they are probably further to fall from June 30, 2008 level. Earnings growth will be harder and harder to get. From one hand we should never discount the resilience of the US economy. There are a lot of companies which are positioned well to weather this period. Still the majority of fund managers dismiss hopes of double-digit earnings growth this and next year as "fantasy".

    It was financial sector propelled by government which rallied. As rotten as they are, they were the top dogs in 2009. Also power of cost cutting was such that it increased revenue of many companies who the whole 2009. Unemployment hit double digits as a result.

    No "multiple bankruptcies and liquidation" for U.S. airlines in 2009. Auto sector benefitted from "cash for clunkers".

  6. [True for 2009] Approximate time for bottoming of real estate is probably around 2-3 years (2010-2011).

    Still there is not bottom. Government subsidies propel sells but foreclosures are still rising.


[Jan 24, 2009] The Never Changing Way of Life

Moon of Alabama

At the Earth Summit in 1992, George H.W. Bush forcefully declared, "The American way of life is not negotiable."

It's the End of the World as We Know It, Baltimore Chronicle, Aug. 3, 2004

My principle focus as vice president has been to protect the American people in our way of life

Transcript: Vice President Cheney on 'FOX News Sunday', Dec. 222, 2008

We will not apologize for our way of life nor will we waver in its defense.
Barack Obama's Inaugural Address, Jan. 20, 2008

[Jan 2, 2009] Robert Reich's Blog Holiday Thoughts about Three Especially Vulnerable Groups

December 27, 2008 | Robert Reich's Blog

I try to be optimistic -- especially this time of year when the days are short and cold, when almost everybody things everyone else is having a better time than they are, and now that we're in the worst economic downturn in almost anyone's memory. Yet I also try to be realistic about the effects of this Mini-Depression. At least three distinct groups are especially vulnerable, each quite differently:

  1. The poor and near poor, with family incomes typically under $20,000 a year. Their connections to the labor force are tenuous at best, often involving part-time and temporary jobs. They're also the first to be let go during downturns. Not surprising, this recession is taking a toll, and about to take a larger one. Few in this group qualify for unemployment insurance, and an increasing number have exhausted the five-year maximum for temporary welfare assistance. To the extent they're getting by, they're moving in with relatives. The media have missed this story almost entirely.
  2. Middle and lower-middle class households whose breadwinners are within five years of being eligible for Social Security. Many are in danger of losing jobs and a large number are already working fewer hours. They're cutting back on all discretionary purchases.

    But their biggest problem is that both their savings and the value of their homes have shrunk dramatically, and probably won't bounce back before they planned to retire.

    Social Security will cover about 40 percent of their pre-retirement earnings. So many are now planning to work well beyond age 65. This will be a particular challenge for blue-collar workers whose earnings have depended largely on physical labor. Their bodies may not last.

  3. Middle and lower-middle class retirees. Most are dependent on income from savings, which has declined sharply. They're cutting expenses where they can, but they're running out of resources. To the extent they can turn to their children for help, they are doing so.

    That means a large and growing cohort of middle-income people between the ages of 35 and 65 have begun subsidizing their parents, even though they and their immediate families are under financial stress. Here's another untold story.

Other Americans are in distress but these three groups are particularly worrisome, and in the years ahead it seems likely they'll be in worse shape than they are today. If this is to be avoided, these three groups will need distinct public policies crafted to their particular needs. More on this to come.

In the meantime, happy holidays.

[Jan 02, 2009] Gold may shine again in 2009 By Martin Hutchinson,

Huge government deficits, low interest rates and rapidly growing money supply all add to the likelihood of renewed inflation - and a rising gold price. How high? Very.

Jan 02, 2009 | Telegraph ( )

First, consider the risks of inflation. US money supply grew slowly for a while in early autumn, but in the two months to December 1 the St Louis Fed's measure of Money of Zero Maturity increased at an 11.7pc annual rate. That's a return to the trend that lasted from 1995 to 2008, when MZM grew 3.6 percentage points faster than nominal GDP.

The US is not alone. Around the world, governments have implemented large stimulus packages. If the corresponding borrowing is not to crowd out the private sector, it must be financed by money supply creation.

This monetary expansion is not supposed to be inflationary, since the governments promise to take any money away before it can push up prices.

But investors can be forgiven for scepticism. Higher inflation is at least possible once the global recession bottoms out. And gold provides good insurance against this outcome.

Demand for gold from investors increased rapidly in 2008, despite a falling price since June. The dollar value of gold demand was 45pc higher in the third quarter than the second, and 51pc above the previous year, according to the World Gold Council. Supply has failed to keep up, with mine output up only 2pc from the previous year and central bank sales down sharply.

Gold's economics are truly mysterious. The commodity demonstrated "negative price elasticity" in 2007, when a higher price produced increased demand.

Nevertheless, weak supply, strong demand and valid fears of inflation constitute a perfect mix of ingredients for building a gold rally. Any surge into gold by hedge funds and other speculators could overwhelm the market, turning the rally into a bubble.

In January, 1980 - just before the Fed led the world out of an inflationary catastrophe, the gold price peaked at $875. That is $2,430 in today's dollars. But the pools of speculative capital are much larger now than in 1980. A true gold bubble could well leave this benchmark far behind.

Top Visited
Past week
Past month


Old News ;-)

Prev | Contents | Next

Recommended Links

Google matched content

Softpanorama Recommended

Top articles

Oldies But Goodies

[Dec 19, 2017] Do not Underestimate the Power of Microfoundations

[Dec 22, 2017] Beyond Cynicism America Fumbles Towards Kafka s Castle by James Howard Kunstler

[Dec 19, 2017] Do not Underestimate the Power of Microfoundations

[Dec 15, 2017] Rise and Decline of the Welfare State, by James Petras

[Dec 05, 2017] Controlling speculation in world financial markets Progressive Christians Uniting by Gordon K Douglass

[Dec 03, 2017] Business Has Killed IT With Overspecialization by Charlie Schluting

[Dec 03, 2017] Another Democratic party betrayal of their former voters. but what you can expect from the party of Bill Clinton?

[Dec 01, 2017] JFK The CIA, Vietnam, and the Plot to Assassinate John F. Kennedy by L. Fletcher Prouty, Oliver Stone, Jesse Ventura

[Nov 30, 2017] Money Imperialism by Michael Hudson

[Nov 29, 2017] Secular Stagnation: The Time for One-Armed Policy is Over

[Nov 29, 2017] Economics is a Belief System - and We are Ruled by Fundamentalists

[Nov 29, 2017] Michael Hudson: The Wall Street Economy is Draining the Real Economy

[Nov 29, 2017] Positive Feedback Loops, Financial Instability, The Blind Spot Of Policymakers

[Nov 29, 2017] Attack on Sanders Economic Plan By Former Chairs of the Council of Economic Advisors Irresponsible

[Nov 27, 2017] College Is Wildly Exploitative Why Arent Students Raising Hell

[Nov 27, 2017] College Is Wildly Exploitative Why Arent Students Raising Hell

[Nov 05, 2017] China and the US Rational Planning and Lumpen Capitalism by James Petras

[Oct 24, 2017] Goldman Sachs ruling America by Gary Rivlin, Michael Hudson

[Oct 16, 2017] Governing is complicated as laws and policies affect a diverse spectrum of people and situations. The average person, in my experience, is not inclined to spend the time necessary to understand good laws/policy in a complex society. The one safety check on mob rule is that most people don't become politically active until their situation is relatively dire

[Oct 13, 2017] Sympathy for the Corporatocracy by C. J. Hopkins

[Oct 11, 2017] Russia witch hunt is a tactic used by the ruling elite, and in particular the Democratic Party, to avoid facing a very unpleasant reality: that their unpopularity is the outcome of their policies of deindustrialization and the assault against working class

[Oct 10, 2017] The US Economy: Explaining Stagnation and Why It Will Persist by Thomas I. Palley

[Oct 08, 2017] Financialization: theoretical analysis and historical perspectives by Costas Lapavitsas

[Feb 26, 2019] THE CRISIS OF NEOLIBERALISM by Julie A. Wilson

[Oct 07, 2017] Finances hold on our everyday life must be broken by Costas Lapavitsas

[Oct 06, 2017] Prof. Philip Mirowski keynote for Life and Debt conference

[Oct 06, 2017] How Economists Turned Corporations into Predators

[Oct 02, 2017] Techs push to teach coding isnt about kids success – its about cutting wages by Ben Tarnoff

[Oct 01, 2017] Bulletproof Neoliberalism by Paul Heideman

[Oct 01, 2017] Neoliberal economic policies in the United States The impact of globalisation on a `Northern country by Kim Scipes

[Sep 25, 2017] Free market as a neoliberal myth, the cornerstone of neoliberalism as a secular religion

[Sep 19, 2017] Neoliberalism: the deep story that lies beneath Donald Trumps triumph: How a ruthless network of super-rich ideologues killed choice and destroyed people's faith in politics by George Monbiot

[Sep 19, 2017] Neoliberalism: the idea that swallowed the world by Stephen Metcalf

[Sep 19, 2017] Neoliberalism: the idea that swallowed the world by Stephen Metcalf

[Sep 19, 2017] Neoliberalism: the deep story that lies beneath Donald Trumps triumph: How a ruthless network of super-rich ideologues killed choice and destroyed people's faith in politics by George Monbiot

[Sep 18, 2017] Critical Realism: Mathematics versus Mythematics in Economics

[Sep 18, 2017] Its always bizarre who easily neoliberals turn into hawkish and warmongering jerks

[Sep 11, 2017] Neo-classical economics as a new flat earth cult

[Sep 11, 2017] The only countervailing force, unions, were deliberately destroyed. Neoliberalism needs to atomize work force to function properly and destroys any solidarity among workers. Unions are anathema for neoliberalism, because they prevent isolation and suppression of workers.

[Sep 11, 2017] Around 1970 corporate managers and professionals realized that they shared the same education, background and interests with capital owners and realigned themselves, abandoning working class and a large part of lower middle class (small business owners)

[Sep 11, 2017] Around 1970 corporate managers and professionals realized that they shared the same education, background and interests with capital owners and realigned themselves, abandoning working class and a large part of lower middle class (small business owners)

[Jul 04, 2017] Summers as a defender of Flat Earth theory

[Jun 17, 2017] The Collapsing Social Contract by Gaius Publius

[May 08, 2017] Karl Polanyi for President by Patrick Iber and Mike Konczal

[May 01, 2017] Trump: A Resisters Guide by Wesley Yang

[Dec 27, 2018] The Yoda of Silicon Valley by Siobhan Roberts

[Dec 25, 2018] The destiny of the USA is now tied to the destiny of neoliberalism (much like the USSR and Bolshevism)

[Dec 11, 2018] John Taylor Gatto s book, The Underground History of American Education, lays out the sad fact of western education ; which has nothing to do with education; but rather, an indoctrination for inclusion in society as a passive participant. Docility is paramount in members of U.S. society so as to maintain the status quo

[Nov 27, 2018] The political fraud of Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez's "Green New Deal"

[Nov 27, 2018] American capitalism could afford to make concessions assiciated with The New Deal because of its economic dominance. The past forty years have been characterized by the continued decline of American capitalism on a world stage relative to its major rivals. The ruling class has responded to this crisis with a neoliberal counterrevolution to claw back all gains won by workers. This policy has been carried out under both Democratic and Republican administrations and with the assistance of the trade unions.

[Nov 23, 2018] Sitting on corruption hill

[Nov 03, 2018] Kunstler The Midterm Endgame Democrats' Perpetual Hysteria

[Sep 29, 2018] Steve Keen How Economics Became a Cult

[Sep 29, 2018] Trump Surrenders to the Iron Law of Oligarchy by Dan Sanchez

[Sep 27, 2018] The power elites goal is to change its appearance to look like something new and innovative to stay ahead of an electorate who are increasingly skeptical of the neoliberalism and globalism that enrich the elite at their expense.

[Sep 25, 2018] The entire documentary "The Spider's Web: Britain's Second Empire" by Michael Oswald is worth watching as an introduction to the corruption in the global finance industry.

[Sep 04, 2018] Kunstler Warns -Some Kind Of Epic National Restructuring Is In The Works

[Aug 22, 2018] The US financial sector has manifestly failed at allocating capital properly and is filled with rent seeking by Anatoly Karlin

[Aug 10, 2018] On Contact: Casino Capitalism with Natasha Dow Schull

[Jul 28, 2018] American Society Would Collapse If It Were not For These 8 Myths by Lee Camp

[Jul 16, 2018] Five Things That Would Make The CIA-CNN Russia Narrative More Believable

[Jul 16, 2018] Why the Media is Desperate to Reclaim its Gatekeeper Status for News Zero Hedge Zero Hedge

[Jul 03, 2018] When you see some really successful financial speculator like Soros or (or much smaller scale) Browder, search for links with intelligence services to explain the success or at least a part of it related to xUSSR space , LA and similar regions

[Jun 25, 2018] The review of A Brief History of Neoliberalism by David Harvey by Michael J. Thompson

[Jun 19, 2018] How The Last Superpower Was Unchained by Tom Engelhardt

[Jun 17, 2018] Neoliberalism as socialism for the banks

[May 31, 2018] Meet the Economist Behind the One Percent's Stealth Takeover of America by Lynn Parramore

[May 30, 2018] How Media Amnesia Has Trapped Us in a Neoliberal Groundhog Day

[May 29, 2018] Guccifer 2.0's American Fingerprints Reveal An Operation Made In The USA by Elizabeth Lea Vos

[May 27, 2018] Northwestern University roundtable discusses regime change in Russia Defend Democracy Press

[Apr 23, 2018] Neoliberals are statists, much like Trotskyites are

[Apr 22, 2018] The American ruling class loves Identity Politics, because Identity Politics divides the people into hostile groups and prevents any resistance to the ruling elite

[Apr 01, 2018] Does the average user care if s/he is micro-targetted by political advertisements based on what they already believe?

[Mar 31, 2018] RFK and Nixon immediately understood the assassination was a CIA-led wet-works operation since they chaired the assassination committees themselves in the past

[Mar 30, 2018] The Death Of The Liberal World Order by Leonid Savin

[Mar 12, 2018] There is no democracy without economic democracy by Jason Hirthler

[Mar 12, 2018] Colonizing the Western Mind using think tanks

[Mar 02, 2018] The main reason much of the highest echelons of American power are united against Trump might be that they're terrified that -- unlike Obama -- he's a really bad salesman for the US led neoliberal empire. This threatens the continuance of their well oiled and exceedingly corrupt gravy train

[Feb 25, 2018] Democracies are political systems in which the real ruling elites hide behind an utterly fake appearance of people power

[Feb 20, 2018] For the life of me I cannot figure why Americans want a war/conflict with Russia

[Feb 11, 2018] How Russiagate fiasco destroys Kremlin moderates, accelerating danger for a hot war

[Feb 10, 2018] The generals are not Borgists. They are something worse ...

[Dec 31, 2017] Is [neo]Liberalism a Dying Faith by Pat Buchanan

[Jan 02, 2019] That madness of the US neocons comes from having no behavioural limits, no references outside of groupthink, and manipulating the language. Simply put, you don't know anymore what's what outside of the narrative your group pushes. The manipulators ends up caught in their lies.




Groupthink : Two Party System as Polyarchy : Corruption of Regulators : Bureaucracies : Understanding Micromanagers and Control Freaks : Toxic Managers :   Harvard Mafia : Diplomatic Communication : Surviving a Bad Performance Review : Insufficient Retirement Funds as Immanent Problem of Neoliberal Regime : PseudoScience : Who Rules America : Neoliberalism  : The Iron Law of Oligarchy : Libertarian Philosophy


War and Peace : Skeptical Finance : John Kenneth Galbraith :Talleyrand : Oscar Wilde : Otto Von Bismarck : Keynes : George Carlin : Skeptics : Propaganda  : SE quotes : Language Design and Programming Quotes : Random IT-related quotesSomerset Maugham : Marcus Aurelius : Kurt Vonnegut : Eric Hoffer : Winston Churchill : Napoleon Bonaparte : Ambrose BierceBernard Shaw : Mark Twain Quotes


Vol 25, No.12 (December, 2013) Rational Fools vs. Efficient Crooks The efficient markets hypothesis : Political Skeptic Bulletin, 2013 : Unemployment Bulletin, 2010 :  Vol 23, No.10 (October, 2011) An observation about corporate security departments : Slightly Skeptical Euromaydan Chronicles, June 2014 : Greenspan legacy bulletin, 2008 : Vol 25, No.10 (October, 2013) Cryptolocker Trojan (Win32/Crilock.A) : Vol 25, No.08 (August, 2013) Cloud providers as intelligence collection hubs : Financial Humor Bulletin, 2010 : Inequality Bulletin, 2009 : Financial Humor Bulletin, 2008 : Copyleft Problems Bulletin, 2004 : Financial Humor Bulletin, 2011 : Energy Bulletin, 2010 : Malware Protection Bulletin, 2010 : Vol 26, No.1 (January, 2013) Object-Oriented Cult : Political Skeptic Bulletin, 2011 : Vol 23, No.11 (November, 2011) Softpanorama classification of sysadmin horror stories : Vol 25, No.05 (May, 2013) Corporate bullshit as a communication method  : Vol 25, No.06 (June, 2013) A Note on the Relationship of Brooks Law and Conway Law


Fifty glorious years (1950-2000): the triumph of the US computer engineering : Donald Knuth : TAoCP and its Influence of Computer Science : Richard Stallman : Linus Torvalds  : Larry Wall  : John K. Ousterhout : CTSS : Multix OS Unix History : Unix shell history : VI editor : History of pipes concept : Solaris : MS DOSProgramming Languages History : PL/1 : Simula 67 : C : History of GCC developmentScripting Languages : Perl history   : OS History : Mail : DNS : SSH : CPU Instruction Sets : SPARC systems 1987-2006 : Norton Commander : Norton Utilities : Norton Ghost : Frontpage history : Malware Defense History : GNU Screen : OSS early history

Classic books:

The Peter Principle : Parkinson Law : 1984 : The Mythical Man-MonthHow to Solve It by George Polya : The Art of Computer Programming : The Elements of Programming Style : The Unix Hater’s Handbook : The Jargon file : The True Believer : Programming Pearls : The Good Soldier Svejk : The Power Elite

Most popular humor pages:

Manifest of the Softpanorama IT Slacker Society : Ten Commandments of the IT Slackers Society : Computer Humor Collection : BSD Logo Story : The Cuckoo's Egg : IT Slang : C++ Humor : ARE YOU A BBS ADDICT? : The Perl Purity Test : Object oriented programmers of all nations : Financial Humor : Financial Humor Bulletin, 2008 : Financial Humor Bulletin, 2010 : The Most Comprehensive Collection of Editor-related Humor : Programming Language Humor : Goldman Sachs related humor : Greenspan humor : C Humor : Scripting Humor : Real Programmers Humor : Web Humor : GPL-related Humor : OFM Humor : Politically Incorrect Humor : IDS Humor : "Linux Sucks" Humor : Russian Musical Humor : Best Russian Programmer Humor : Microsoft plans to buy Catholic Church : Richard Stallman Related Humor : Admin Humor : Perl-related Humor : Linus Torvalds Related humor : PseudoScience Related Humor : Networking Humor : Shell Humor : Financial Humor Bulletin, 2011 : Financial Humor Bulletin, 2012 : Financial Humor Bulletin, 2013 : Java Humor : Software Engineering Humor : Sun Solaris Related Humor : Education Humor : IBM Humor : Assembler-related Humor : VIM Humor : Computer Viruses Humor : Bright tomorrow is rescheduled to a day after tomorrow : Classic Computer Humor

The Last but not Least Technology is dominated by two types of people: those who understand what they do not manage and those who manage what they do not understand ~Archibald Putt. Ph.D

Copyright © 1996-2021 by Softpanorama Society. was initially created as a service to the (now defunct) UN Sustainable Development Networking Programme (SDNP) without any remuneration. This document is an industrial compilation designed and created exclusively for educational use and is distributed under the Softpanorama Content License. Original materials copyright belong to respective owners. Quotes are made for educational purposes only in compliance with the fair use doctrine.

FAIR USE NOTICE This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available to advance understanding of computer science, IT technology, economic, scientific, and social issues. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided by section 107 of the US Copyright Law according to which such material can be distributed without profit exclusively for research and educational purposes.

This is a Spartan WHYFF (We Help You For Free) site written by people for whom English is not a native language. Grammar and spelling errors should be expected. The site contain some broken links as it develops like a living tree...

You can use PayPal to to buy a cup of coffee for authors of this site


The statements, views and opinions presented on this web page are those of the author (or referenced source) and are not endorsed by, nor do they necessarily reflect, the opinions of the Softpanorama society. We do not warrant the correctness of the information provided or its fitness for any purpose. The site uses AdSense so you need to be aware of Google privacy policy. You you do not want to be tracked by Google please disable Javascript for this site. This site is perfectly usable without Javascript.

Last modified: April 22, 2019